August 25, 2010 17:56

Q&A: 10-Candle Strategy and Drawdown

Posted In: CandlePro, Forex Q&A
By:

Understanding how CandlePro uses the 10-Candle Strategy and how drawdown is calculated within that system is key to really seeing through the system, and seeing through the system will ultimately help you utilize the tool better in your trading.

I’ve put together this Q&A to help everyone benefit from the answers I’ve given in emails and chat posts about 10-Candle Strategy and drawdown. Here goes:


Question #1 – Hey, I think the drawdown numbers are wrong in CP! When I look at the 10 candles after a signal it went down X pips and CP lists it as Y pips. What gives?

Answer: If you think there is a discrepancy then you should email me (support@piphut.com) so I can take a look but read this first:  99/100 times CP is functioning perfectly but you need to understand how the drawdown is calculated. The drawdown is the most the pair moved against your BEFORE hitting the 10 candle profit – anything after is discarded as the purpose is to know where to put our stop-loss to hit the 10-candle profit.



Question #2 – Why is it set up that way?

Answer: It helps to think about what we are trying to know: ON AVERAGE, how much does the pair move AGAINST (drawdown) our position before hitting the highest AVERAGE point in 10 candles (10-candle profit). If we were to take all 10 candles into consideration for the drawdown it would no longer tell us where to put our stop-loss to get to the 10-candle High, it would tell us where to put our stop-loss to get through 10 candles, regardless of what the 10-candle high is. Which isn’t very useful.



Question #3 – I’m still confused. What if it moved in your favor 30 pips first 5 candles then down 60 pips last 5 candles for a loss of 30 pips, is the candle profit 30 and drawdown 30?

Answer: In your example your 10-candle profit = +30. Your drawdown would be the most the pair moved against you BEFORE that fifth candle.

Let me see if I can draw this out with letters. Here is what I know from your example above:

X X X X +30 X X X X -30

Those ‘X’s represent the current profit of the pair. Let me add some values to that:

5 -10 0 20 30 X X X X -30

Now the drawdown is -10, because that is the most the pair moved against your BEFORE hitting the 10 candle profit (which it hit on the 5th candle ’30′).



Question #4: What if it moved up one pip the first candle then back down to entry and stays the the rest of first candle , then down 15 for the last 9 , since the first candle was the 10 candle profit level (1 pip) with out ever going against you, would that not make the drawdown 0 instead of -15?

Answer: Yes, that would make the drawdown 0 and the 10-candle profit +1. Not a very compelling candlestick setup!



Question #5: Doesn’t this skew the stats? Meaning that if this is the case if the price moves the right way just a little (before reaching any reasonable profit target) and then moves against you dramatically, CandlePro will NOT report any negative move that happens after the correct move, even if it’s within the 10 candle. However, if it’s the other way around, Candle Pro will report the dramatic correct move which went the correct way within 10 candle.

Answer: This would be true if we were only looking at one signal. The power of CP is that it gives us crunches the data on up to 50 previous signals and gives us all the averages/data which means that:

  1. If a pair does this often then the RR ratio (both median and average are provided) will be bad because 10-candle profit will be small and the trade wouldn’t be taken in the first place then
  2. This is also why I recommend looking at “past trades” in the videos – to confirm the pair has healthy profit levels
  3. This is also why I recommend using a SL for all trades (and as an experienced trader I’m sure I’m preaching to choir here) – because no trade is guaranteed and if it moves against you the max you should lose is your SL. Luckily CP analyzes the past signals to give you a good starting point of where to put your SL.



Question#6: I get it now!

Answer: That’s not a question, but great! Remember CP is great in that in crunches all of that historical data for you to make your trades smarter. As stated in all the launch material, user guide, etc., CP is not a strategy in and of itself – it is first a candlestick scanner and second a candlestick analyzer and the real power lies in its crunching of historical data. That historical data (i.e. the performance report) allows you to make smarter trades based off of candlesticks.


The 10-Candle Strategy in one sentence:

10-Candle Strategy tells us this: ON AVERAGE, how much does the pair move AGAINST (drawdown) our position before hitting the highest AVERAGE point in 10 candles (10-candle profit). Knowing this and understanding this helps makes better trades based off CP data.

15 Comments on "Q&A: 10-Candle Strategy and Drawdown"
  1. Avatar of abeoljkc1
    Comment left on:
    August 25, 2010 at 19:18
    abeoljkc1 says:

    Thanks for the explanation!!
    Only now I completely understand, how CP works.
    Thanks again.

  2. Avatar of chaseknight
    Comment left on:
    September 7, 2010 at 04:34
    chaseknight says:

    So “10 candle loss” is the draw down before hitting “10 candle profit”?

    • Avatar of piphut
      Comment left on:
      September 7, 2010 at 05:00
      piphut says:

      Exactly. Maybe I should change that terminology to just “drawdown” to better reflect its purpose?

  3. Avatar of chaseknight
    Comment left on:
    September 7, 2010 at 05:07
    chaseknight says:

    Thanks I just wanted to make sure and maybe that would help people understand it.

  4. Avatar of chaseknight
    Comment left on:
    September 7, 2010 at 07:07
    chaseknight says:

    Just an idea what is your thoughts on a maximum 10 candle high/loss of pips?

    • Avatar of piphut
      Comment left on:
      September 7, 2010 at 07:11
      piphut says:

      The maximum depends a lot on which timeframe you are looking at. You can see MAX averages for each pair/signal by clicking on the “Performance Report” of that signal

  5. Avatar of chaseknight
    Comment left on:
    September 7, 2010 at 07:29
    chaseknight says:

    Now are those max averages just for that one candle or ten candles?

    • Avatar of piphut
      Comment left on:
      September 7, 2010 at 07:33
      piphut says:

      data in the performance report is based on all the past signals analyzed (up to 50 signals!), including averages

  6. Comment left on:
    September 27, 2010 at 18:12
    hooman majidi says:

    hi my dear friend MR MARK.how i can use this sterategy?p.s explain me.thanks alot. hooman

  7. Comment left on:
    January 25, 2011 at 16:30
    johnamirtharaj says:

    hi mark ,
    your candle pro signal report is great.i and my friends want like to join ur pro member.but here no one have credit card.so please allow any other option to send the money .(now i am apply to credit card for only buy ur pro). if u accept other money transfer method it s helpful for many my country traders. ur work is very great .thanks

  8. Avatar of shuurai
    Comment left on:
    February 16, 2011 at 11:13
    shuurai says:

    I have tried to ask in Chatroom, anyway just incase someone can clarify here.

    How come in the performance chart in any signal, the Average drawback is a positive number and the Median drawback is a negative number? I would assume all drawback would be negative number, so the average of a lot of negative numbers should still be negative?

  9. Avatar of ishu
    Comment left on:
    March 10, 2011 at 10:36
    ishu says:

    dear
    pls note that i made the payment … But i cant use the signal s

    Pls Advise

    My USER ID : ishu

  10. Avatar of jamweisse
    Comment left on:
    March 12, 2011 at 05:35
    jamweisse says:

    Hi mark ..
    is there any other way to pay except paypla, because i have problomes with my paypal account.

    thanks

  11. Comment left on:
    June 1, 2011 at 14:20
    racheal says:

    pls i really want to subscribe for your signals but here in my country paypal is not accepted do you have any other payment system that i can send money through.
    thanks.

    • Avatar of piphut
      Comment left on:
      June 1, 2011 at 17:33
      piphut says:

      Hi Racheal, your time is perfect. We just launched Google Checkout as a PayPal alternative to those who have been waiting (some have been waiting for 10 months). If you sign up before June 3rd there is a special offer… :
      http://piphut.com/google-checkout/

Leave A Comment
XHTML: feel free to use any of these tags.

LEGAL DISCLAIMER AND RISK WARNING

Foreign currency exchange trading is highly speculative and is suitable only for those who (a) understand and are willing to assume the risks involved, and (b) are financially able to assume significant economic losses. The possibility exists that you could sustain a loss of some or all of your initial investment and therefore you should not invest money that you cannot afford to lose. Trading on margin can amplify both gains and losses in your account. Before deciding to trade foreign currencies, you should carefully consider your investment objectives, level of experience, and risk appetite. You should be aware of all the risks associated with foreign currency exchange trading and seek advice from an independent financial advisor if you have any doubts.

All contents or information displayed or contained on Piphut.com are based on a number of assumptions which may not be fully disclosed or explained. Hypothetical trading or performance has many inherent limitations, including the benefit of hindsight and the fact hypothetical trading or performance involves no economic risk. Variables such as the ability to adhere to a particular trading program despite trading losses and maintaining adequate liquidity are material considerations that can adversely affect actual trading results. No representation or warranty is being made or given that any account will or is likely to achieve profits or losses similar to those displayed on Piphut.com. There are frequently substantial differences between hypothetical performance and the actual performance subsequently achieved by a trading program. You must exercise independent judgment when making investment or trading decisions. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Please read the User Agreement and Risk Disclosure Statement for more information.